Animated Accessories or Poetical Trappings? Botticelli’s Primavera Among Walter Pater, Aby Warburg and Edgar Wind

Robert Pawlik Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University in Warsaw

Volume 4, April 2023

Abstract
This paper focuses on two readings of Botticelli’s “Primavera”: firstly, one advanced by German art
historian Aby Warburg in his 1893 doctoral dissertation; and secondly, one that was presented over
sixty years later by a philosopher and a member of Warburg’s circle Edgar Wind in his “Pagan
Mysteries in the Renaissance”. Discussion of both readings is placed against the background of
Walter Pater’s 1870 essay on Sandro Botticelli – a milestone in the history of rediscovery of the
Florentine master after 300 hundred years of oblivion. Bringing Walter Pater to the fore exposes
the polemical dimension of Warburg’s dissertation as well as its entanglement in the debates on the
nature of the Renaissance as the turning point towards the modern era. But it also helps to see
more clearly the respective positions of Aby Warburg and Edgar Wind.

Keywords
Sandro Botticelli; Primavera; Walter Pater; Aby Warburg; Edgar Wind; Renaissance; modernity;
epicureanism; Neoplatonism

[pdf]

Bibliography

Allan, Judith R., Simonetta Cattaneo Vespucci: Beauty, politics, literature and art in early Renaissance Florence, Ph.D thesis, University of Birmingham (2014).

Ames-Lewis, F., ‘Neoplatonism and the Visual Arts at the Time of Marsilio Ficino’, in Marsilio Ficino: His Theology, His Philosophy, His Legacy, ed. by M. Allen and V. Rees (Leiden: Brill, 2002), pp. 327–338.

Arasse, Daniel, ‘Botticelli’s Manner’, in Botticelli: from Lorenzo the Magnificent to Savonarola, ed. by Daniel Arasse and Pierluigi de Vecchi (Milano: Skira, 2003), pp. 13–23.

Bagemihl, Rolf, ‘Francesco Botticini’s Palmieri Altar-Piece’, The Burlington Magazine, 138 (1996) s. 308–314.

Barolsky, Paul, ‘Walter Pater’s Renaissance’, Virginia Quarterly Review, 58.2 (1982), pp. 208–220.

Baxandall, Michael, Painting and Experience in 15th century Italy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1972).

Bertram, Anthony, ‘The English Discovery of Botticelli’, Journal of the Royal Society of Arts, 98 (1950), s. 468–484.

Bloom, Harold, ‘Water Pater: The Intoxication of Belatedness’, Yale French Studies, 50 (1974), pp. 163–189.

Branca, Bernardino, Edgar Wind. Filosofo delle immagini: La biografia intellettuale di un discepolo di Aby Warburg (Milano: Mimesis 2019).

Bredekamp, Horst, ‘Götterdämmerung des Neuplatonismus’, in Die Lesbarkeit der Kunst: Zur Geistes-Gegenwart der Ikonologie, ed. by A. Beyer (Berlin: Wagenbach 1992), pp. 75–83, 102–106.

—, Sandro Botticelli La Primavera: Florenz als Garten der Venus (Frankfurt a. M: Fischer Taschenbuch-Verlag, 1993).

—, B. Buschendorf, F. Hartung, and J. Krois, eds., Edgar Wind – Kunsthistoriker und Philosoph (Berlin: Akademie Verlag 1998).

Brown, Alison, The Return of Lucretius to Renaissance Florence (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2010).

Buschendorf, Bernhard, ‘War ein sehr tüchtiges gegenseitiges Fördern: Edgar Wind und Aby Warburg’, Idea: Jahrbuch der Hamburger Kunsthalle, 4 (1985), pp. 165–209.

—, ‘Zur Begründung der Kulturwissenschaft. Der Symbolbegriff bei Friedrich Theodor Vischer, Aby Warburg und Edgar Wind’, in Edgar Wind – Kunsthistoriker und Philosoph, ed. by H. Bredekamp, B. Buschendorf, F. Hartung, and J. Krois (Akademie Verlag Berlin, 1998), pp. 227–248.

Cassirer, Ernst, ‘Eidos und Eidolon: Das Problem des Schönen und der Kunst in Platons Dialogen’, Vorträge der Bibliothek Warburg 2 (1922–1923) (Leipzig and Berlin: Teubner 1924), pp. 1–27 [‘Eidos and Eidolon’, in The Warburg Years (1919–1933): Essays on Language, Art, Myth, and Technology, ed. by E. Cassirer trans. and intro. by S. G. Lofts with A. Calcagno (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2013), pp. 214–243].

Centanni, Monica and Alessandra Pedersoli, ‘Costantino XI Paleologo vs Maometto II. Nota sulla cronologia della Battaglia di Costantino contro Massenzio di Piero della Francesca in San Francesco ad Arezzo’, Engramma, 52 (2006), pp. 1–18.

Cheeke, Stephen, ‘“Fantastic Modernism”: Walter Pater, Botticelli, and Simonetta’, Word & Image, 32:2 (2016), pp. 195–206.

Coates, John, ‘Variations on the Oxford Temper: Swinburne, Pater and Botticelli’, English Literature in Transition, 1880-1920, vol. 40 no. 3, (1997), pp. 260–274.

Contarini, Silvia, ‘“Botticelli Ritrovato”: Frammenti di dialogo tra Aby Warburg e André Jolles’, Prospettiva, 68 (1992), pp. 87–93.

Christian, Margareta I., ‘Aer, Aurae, Venti: Philology and Physiology in Aby Warburg’s Dissertation on Botticelli’, PMLA, vol. 129, no. 3 (2014), pp. 399–416.

Crasta, Fabrizio, ‘Gli Angeli Neutrali Da Dante a Matteo Palmieri’, Lettere Italiane, vol. 67, no. 1, (2015), pp. 5–25.

Debenedetti, Ana and Caroline Elam (eds.), Botticelli Past and Present (London: UCL Press, 2019).

Didi-Huberman, Georges, ‘Alla ricerca delle fonti perdute. Warburg e il tempo della Primavera’, Aut Aut, 321- 322 (2004), pp. 84–96.

Dempsey, Charles, The Portrayal of Love: Botticelli’s Primavera and Humanist Culture at the Time of Lorenzo the Magnificent (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1992).

Engel, Franz, ‘“Though this Be Madness”: Edgar Wind and the Warburg Tradition’, in Bildaktat the Warburg Institute, ed. by S. Marienberg and J. Trabant (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2014), pp. 87–116.

Evans, Mark, and S. Weppelmann, (eds.), Botticelli Reimagined (London: V&A Publishing, 2016).

Ettle, Ross B., ‘The Venus Dilemma: Notes on Botticelli and Simonetta Cattaneo Vespucci’, Source: Notes in the History of Art, vol. 27, no. 4, (2008), pp. 3–10.

Ferguson, Wallace K., The Renaissance in Historical Thought: Five Centuries of Interpretation (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1948).

Ferraro, A.M., ‘Matteo Palmieri’s City of Life: The Original Idea of Three Opportunities for Salvation’, International Journal of Literature and Arts, vol. 2, 6 (2014), pp. 230–239.

Freccero, John, ‘Dante and the Neutral Angels’, The Romantic Review, 1 (1960), pp. 3–14.

Fry, Roger E., ‘Sandro Botticelli’, The Burlington Magazine, XLVIII (1926), pp. 196–200.

Garin, Eugenio, ‘Enigmatic Veils’, The Burlington Magazine, 101 (1959), pp. 73–74.

Ghelardi, Maurizio, ‘Edgar Wind su Aby Warburg: un esercizio ermeneutico, con: Appendice di testi inediti di Edgard Wind sulle riflessioni di Warburg su Botticelli’, Engramma, 150 October (2017), pp. 625–635.

Gombrich, Ernst H., ‘Botticelli’s Mythologies: A Study in the Neoplatonic Symbolism of His Circle’, Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 8 (1945), pp. 7–60.

—, Aby Warburg: An Intellectual Biography (Oxford: Phaidon, 1986).

—, ‘Aby Warburg: His Aims and Methods: An Anniversary Lecture’, Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 62 (1999), pp. 268–282.

Greenblatt, Stephen, The Swerve: How the World Became Modern (New York: W. W. Norton, 2011).

Hadot, Pierre, ‘Métaphysique et Images. Entretien avec Pierre Hadot’, Préfaces: les idées et les sciences dans la bibliographie de la France (1992), pp. 33–37.

Haskell, Francis, Rediscoveries in Art: Some Aspects of Taste, Fashion and Collecting in England and France (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1976).

Hatfield, Rab, ‘Some Misidentifications in and of Works by Botticelli’, in Sandro Botticelli and Herbert Horne: New Research, ed. by R. Hatfield (Florence: Syracuse University Press 2009), pp. 7–61.

Hönes, Hans C., ‘Warburg’s Positivism: Confessions of a Truffle Pig’, Oxford Art Journal, vol. 41, no. 3 (2018), pp. 361–379.

Hub, Berthold, and Sergius Kodera, eds., Iconology, Neoplatonism, and the Arts in the Renaissance (New York and London: Routledge, 2020).

Iser, Wolfgang, Walter Pater: The Aesthetic Moment, trans. By David Henry Wilson (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987).

Kermode, Frank, ‘Botticelli Recovered’, in F. Kermode, Forms of Attention (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1985), pp. 3–31.

Körner, Hans, ‘Simonetta Vespucci: the construction, deconstruction, and reconstruction of a myth’, in Botticelli: likeness, myth, devotion: an exhibition organized by the Städel Museum, ed. by A. Schumacher, Frankfurt am Main, November 13, 2009–February 28, 2010, (Ostfildern, 2009), pp. 57–70.

Lailach, Michael, ‘Das Paradigma der Edgar Winds Interpretation in Edgar Winds’, in „Die heidnischen Mysterien der Renaissance“’, ed. by H. Bredekamp and B. Buschendorf, Kunsthistoriker und Philosoph (Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 1998), pp. 105–116.

Levey, Michael, Botticelli and Nineteenth-Century England, Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, vols. 3–4 (1960), pp. 291–306.

Lyons, Richard S., ‘The “Complex, Many-Sided” Unity of The Renaissance’, Studies in English Literature, 1500-1900, vol. 12, no. 4 (1972), pp. 765–81.

Lyons, Sara, ‘Life as the End of Life: Algernon Charles Swinburne, Walter Pater, and Secular Aesthetics’ (PhD thesis, Queen Mary University of London, 2013).

Melius, Jeremy N., ‘Art History and the Invention of Botticelli’, PhD thesis (Berkeley: University of California, 2010).

Moffitt, John F., ‘The Neoplatonic Bacchus of the Renaissance’, in Inspiration: Bacchus and the Cultural History of a Creation Myth, ed. by J.F. Moffitt (Leiden: Brill, 2005), pp. 129–150.

Nelson, Jonathan K., ‘Botticelli’s “Virile Air”: Reconsidering the Milan Memo of 1493’, in Sandro Botticelli: Artist and Entrepreneur in Renaissance Florence, ed. by G.J. van der Sman and I. Mariani (Firenze: Centro Di, 2015), pp. 167–180.

Panofsky, Erwin, Idea: Ein Beitrag zur Begriffsgeschichte der älteren Kunsttheorie, (Leipzig and Berlin: Teubner, 1924).

—, ‘The Neoplatonic Movement in Florence and North Italy (Bandinelli and Titian)’, in Studies in Iconology: Humanistic Themes in the Art of the Renaissance (New York: Harper & Row, 1939), pp. 129–170.

—, ‘The Neoplatonic Movement and Michelangelo’, Studies in Iconology (1939), pp. 171–230.

—, Studies in Iconology: Humanistic Themes in the Art of the Renaissance (New York: Harper & Row, 1939).

Papapetros, Spyros, ‘The Eternal Seesaw: Oscillations in Warburg’s Revival’, Oxford Art Journal, vol. 26, no. 2 (2003) pp. 169–176.

Passannante, Gerard, The Lucretian Renaissance: Philology and the Afterlife of Tradition (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2011).

Pater, Walter, ‘A Fragment on Sandro Botticelli’, The Fortnightly Review, August (1870), pp. 155–160.

—, The Renaissance: Studies in Art and Poetry, (London and Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980).

Pérez, Xosé A.A., ‘Un nuovo contributo allo studio del mito degli angeli neutrali nella Commedia’, Revista de Literatura Medieval, XXI (2009), pp. 37–75.

Quiviger, François, ‘Neither Drunk nor Sober. Dionysiac Inspiration and Renaissance Artistic Practices’, in Iconology, Neoplatonism, and the Arts in the Renaissance (New York and London: Routledge, 2020), pp. 200–215.

Rampley, Matthew, ‘From Symbol to Allegory: Aby Warburg’s Theory of Art’, The Art Bulletin, 79 (1997), pp. 41–55.

Reale, Giovanni, Botticelli. La “Primavera” o le “Nozze di Filologia e Mercurio”? (Rimini: Idea Libri, 2001).

Roeck, Bernd, Florence 1900. The Quest for Arcadia, trans. S. Spencer (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 2009).

Del Riccio, Eleonora, ‘Details and Expression. Giovanni Morelli’s Model and Aby Warburg’s “Types” in Connection with Experimental Psychology during the 19th Century’, Art and Art History, vol. 8 no. 1 (2020), pp. 58–66.

Saxl, Fritz, ‘Die Bibliothek Warburg und ihr Ziel’, Vorträge der Bibliothek Warburg (1921–1922), pp. 1–10.

Schmitt, Carl, The Age of Neutralizations and Depoliticizations, trans. M. Konzett and J.P. McCormick, Telos: Critical Theory of the Contemporary, 96 (1993), pp. 130–142.

Schoell-Glass, Charlotte, ‘La mort d’Orphée ou le retour de la bestialité: Aby Warburg et l’antisémitisme’, Revue Germanique Internationale, 17 (2002), pp. 111–126.

—, ‘Superlative der Gebärdensprache: Kindermord’, in Bild/Geschichte: Festschrift für Horst Bredekamp, ed. By P. Helas, M. Polte, C. Rückert and B. Uppenkamp (Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 2007), pp. 155–170.

—, ‘Aby Warburg’s Late Comments on Symbol and Ritual’, Science in Context, 12, 4 (1999), pp. 621–642.

Sears, Elizabeth, ‘Kenneth Clark and Gertrud Bing: Letters on The Nude’, The Burlington Magazine, 1301 (2011), pp. 530–531.

Shearman, John, ‘The Collections of the Younger Branch of the Medici’, The Burlington Magazine, 117 (1975), pp. 12–27.

Sliwka, Jennifer, Visions of Paradise: Botticini’s Palmieri Altarpiece (London: National Gallery Company, 2015).

Smith, Webster, ‘On the Original Location of the Primavera’, The Art Bulletin, 1 (1975), pp. 31–40.

Stimilli, Davide, ‘Aby Warburg in America Again: With an Edition of His Unpublished Correspondence with Edwin R. A. Seligman (1927–1928)’, RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics, 48 (2005), pp. 193–206.

Sullivan, William H., ‘Four Early Studies from Pater’s The Renaissance: The Aesthetics for a Humanist Myth’, The Victorian Newsletter, 40 (1971), pp. 1–7.

Takaes, Ianick, ‘L’esprit de Warburg lui-même sera en paix (A survey of Edgar Wind’s quarrel with the Warburg Institute)’, Engramma, 153 (2018), pp. 109–182.

Tononi, Fabio, ‘Aby Warburg, Edgar Wind, and the Concept of Kulturwissenschaft: Reflections on Imagery, Symbols, and Expression’, The Edgar Wind Journal, 2 (2022), pp. 38–74.

Toussaint, Stéphane, ‘My Friend Ficino: Art History and Neoplatonism from Intellectual to Material Beauty’, Mitteilungen des Kunsthistorischen Institutes in Florenz, vol. 59, no. 2 (2017), pp. 147–173.

Tucker, Paul, ‘“Reanimate Greek”: Pater and Ruskin on Botticelli’, in Walter Pater: Transparencies of Desire, ed. by L. Brake, L. Higgins and C. Williams (Greensboro, NC: ELT Press, 2002), pp. 119–132, 320–323.

Vasari, Giorgio, The Lives of the Artists, trans. and intro. by J. C. Bondanella and P. Bondanella (Oxford, 1991).

Via, Claudia C., ‘Menschenopfer’, Images Re-vues 4 (2013), http://journals.openedition.org/imagesrevues/29.

Villa, Claudia, ‘Per una lettura della Primavera, Mercurio ‘retrogrado’ e la Retorica nella bottega di Botticelli’, Strumenti critici, Rivista quadrimestrale di cultura e critica letteraria 1 (1998), pp. 1–28.

Wallen, Jeffrey, ‘Alive in the Grave: Walter Pater’s Renaissance’, ELH, vol. 66, no. 4 (1999), pp. 1033–1051.

Warburg, Aby, Gesammelte Schriften, vol II.2, Bilderreihen und Ausstellungen, ed. by Uwe Fleckner, Isabella Woldt (Berlin: Oldenbourg Verlag, 2012).

—, ‘Bildniskunst und florentinisches Bürgertum: Domenico Ghirlandajo in Santa Trinità: Bildnisse des Lorenzo de’ Medici und seiner Angehörigen’, Leipzig 1902. [The Art of Portraiture and the Florentine Bourgeoisie Domenico Ghirlandaio in Santa Trinita: The Portraits of Lorenzo de’ Medici and His Household, [in:] Aby Warburg, The Renewal of Pagan Antiquity (Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute for the History of Art and the Humanities, 1999, pp. 185–221)].

—, I Costumi teatrali per gli intermezzi del 1589, Atti dell’Accademia del Regio Istituto Musicale di Firenze, XXXIII (1895), pp. 133–146 [Aby Warburg, Theatrical Costumes for the Intermedi of 1589, in Aby Warburg, The Renewal of Pagan Antiquity (Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute for the History of Art and the Humanities, 1999, pp. 349–401]).

—, ‘Einleitung’ [in:] Der Bilderatlas Mnemosyne, Berlin: Akademie Verlag 2000. [The Absorption of the Expressive Values of the Past, trans. Matthew Rampley, Art in Translation (2009), pp. 273–283].

—, ‘Der Eintritt des antikisierenden Idealstils in die Malerei der Frührenaissance’, in Werke in einem Band, Martin Treml (eds.), Berlin 2010, pp. 281–310 [‘The Entry of the Idealizing Classical Style in the Painting of Early Renaissance’, trans. by Matthew Rampley, in Art History as Cultural History: Warburg’s Projects, ed. by Richard Woodfield (London and New York, 2001), pp. 7–31].

—, ‘Italienische Kunst und internationale Astrologie im Palazzo Schifanoia in Ferrara, ed. by A. Venturi, L’Italia e l’arte straniera: atti del X Congresso Internazionale di Storia dell’Arte in Roma (1912), Roma 1922, pp. 179–193. [‘Italian Art and International Astrology in the Palazzo Schifanoia, Ferrara’, in Aby Warburg, The Renewal of Pagan Antiquity (Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute for the History of Art and the Humanities, 1999, pp. 563–591].

—, Piero della Francescas Constantinschlacht in der Aquarellcopie des Johann Anton Ramboux, [in:] L’Italia e l’arte staniera: Atti del X Congresso internazionale di storia dell’arte a Roma, [1912] Adolfo Venturi (ed.), Roma 1922, pp. 326–327. [Aby Warburg, Piero della Francesca’s ‘Battle of Constantine’ in the Watercolor Copy by Johann Anton Ramboux (1912) in Aby Warburg, The Renewal of Pagan Antiquity, op. cit., 339–342].

—, The Renewal of Pagan Antiquity, trans. David Britt (Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute for the History of Art and the Humanities, 1999).

—, Sandro Botticellis Geburt der ‘Venus’ und ‘Frühling’: eine Untersuchung über die Vorstellungen von der Antike in der italienischen Frührenaissance, Hamburg-Leipzig 1893 [Sandro Botticelli’s ‘Birth of Venus’ and ‘Spring’: An Examination of Concepts of Antiquity in the Italian Early Renaissance, in Aby Warburg, The Renewal of Pagan Antiquity, trans. D. Britt. Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute for the History of Art and the Humanities 1999, pp. 89–156].

—, Sandro Botticelli, Das Museum: eine Anleitung zum Genuß der Werke bildender Kunst, 3 (1898), pp. 37–40. [ Sandro Botticelli (1898), in The Renewal of Pagan Antiquity (Los Angeles: Getty Research Institute for the History of Art and the Humanities, 1999, pp. 157–164)].

Warnke, Martin, ‘Individuality as Argument. Piero della Francesca’s Portrait of the Duke and the Duchess of Urbino’, in The Image of the Individual. Portraits in the Renaissance, ed. by N. Mann and L. Syson (London: British Museum Press, 1998), pp. 81–90, 213–215.

Wedepohl, Claudia, ‘Aby Warburg und die Aquarellkopie des Johann Anton Ramboux nach Piero della Francescas ‘Konstantinsschlacht’ in Arezzo’, in Artiummconjunctio: Kulturwissenschaft und Frühneuzeitforschung; Aufsätze für Dieter Wuttke, ed. by P. Schöner and G. Hübner (Koerner: Baden-Baden, 2013), pp. 347–380.

—, ‘Why Botticelli?: Aby Warburg’s Search for a New Approach to Quattrocento Italian Art’, in Botticelli Past and Present, ed. by Ana Debenedetti and Caroline Elam (London, 2019), pp. 183–202.

Weinberg, Gail S., ‘Ruskin, Pater, and the Rediscovery of Botticelli’, The Burlington Magazine, vol. 129, no. 1006 (1987), pp. 25–27.

Wind, Edgar, Art and Anarchy: the Reith Lectures (London: Faber and Faber, 1963).

—, Bellini’s Feast of the Gods: A Study in Venetian Humanism (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1948).

—, The Eloquence of Symbols: Studies in Humanist Art, ed. by J. Anderson (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983).

—, Hume and the Heroic Portrait: Studies in Eighteenth-century Imagery, ed. by J. Anderson (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986).

—, Pagan Mysteries in the Renaissance (London: Faber and Faber, 1958).

—, ‘The Revival of Origen’, Edgar Wind, The Eloquence of Symbols: Studies in Humanist Art, ed. by Jaynie Anderson (Oxford, 1983), pp. 42–56.

—, ‘Warburgs Begriff der Kulturwissenschaft und seine Bedeutung für die Ästhetik’, Beilageheft zur Zeitschrift für Ästhetik und allgemeine Kunstwissenschaft J. 25 (1931), pp. 163–179 [‘Warburg’s Concept of Kulturwissenschaft and its Meaning for Aesthetics’ in The Eloquence of Symbols: Studies in Humanist Art, ed. by J. Anderson (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983), pp. 21–35].

Wittkower, Rudolf, Architectural Principles in the Age of Humanism (London: The Warburg Institute, 1949).

Zambrano, Patrizia, ‘Sandro Botticelli and the Birth of Modern Portraiture’, in Botticelli Past and Present (London: UCL Press, 2019), pp. 10–35.

Zorach, Rebecca, ‘Love, Truth, Orthodoxy, Reticence; or, What Edgar Wind Didn’t See in Botticelli’s Primavera’, Critical Inquiry, vol. 34, no. 1 (2007), pp. 190–224.

Zöllner, Frank, ‘Zu den Quellen und zur Ikonographie von Sandro Botticellis Primavera’, Wiener Jahrbuch für Kunstgeschichte, 50 (1997), pp. 131–157, pp. 357–366.